Thursday, December 21, 2017

Christmas Memories

CHRISTMAS MEMORIES
 By Bertha Malvina Thurber Butler

The first Christmas I remember very well was when I was a small child in Grass Valley, Utah. I knew there was something in mother’s trunk for me, and one day when she was away I removed the lock and found a pretty plaid piece of cloth for a dress. (I was a naughty child, but doubt if she knew it). It was about this time that I received a doll – it was about ten inches tall, a cloth body stuffed with sawdust, and a china head with black painted hair. The only real doll I ever had.

After moving to Richfield in 1889, we lived neighbors to Nebeker’s. Norie (Lanoria) Nebeker was about my age and we became very close friends. One Christmas eve, she wagered that she would be first to say “Christmas gift” the next morning. So, on Christmas morning very early I went cautiously to their door and called my greeting, and was much chagrined when she presented me with a small pair of china statues (dolls). I had not expected any gift of that kind.

One Christmas in Richfield, Mr. and Mrs. Santa Claus had arrived and were presenting gifts from a beautiful tree lighted with candles. Suddenly Mr. Santa caught his clothing on fire. He got outside and the fire was put out without any serious damage.

The Christmas of 1898 was a different one for me. My cousin, Vina Bushnell, of Meadow, had been living at our home and attending school. Her father came to take her home for the holidays, and I went with them and had a very lovely time visiting with my Aunt Elizabeth Bushnell and her numerous family. I was gone from home about two weeks. It was this Christmas time that my dear John was doing missionary work in Minnesota and his father died December 30th. I was away from home and did not know of his death at the time. He had been in very poor health for a long time, had dropsy. The family were practically without funds and had a very meager Christmas. Jane tells of how the children fixed up a tree of some kind, putting spools of thread, scissors or anything available on, to distribute as gifts. Happy children they were and enjoyed the fun, but the dear father, who was so ill, shed tears when he saw their efforts. He loved his family and knew he was about to leave them.

The next Christmas, 1899, we had been married about six weeks and were at a mine about two miles over the mountains from Kimberly on Gold Mountain. John and Jack Gilbert were contracting there. We were snowed in, and isolated. No way to get to town except on snow shoes or skis. I think we were very much alone for Christmas as the other men working there had gone to the Valley.

The Christmas of 1901 we were still at the mines, but now living at Kimberly and working at the Anna Laura. We all went home to Richfield for Christmas, where the entire Butler family met together and had the family picture taken. John and I also had our first picture taken together.

We moved to Idaho in 1904, and there we had our children growing up in the home. We always had our Christmas tree, as the men would get one from the mountains very easily, while hauling wood. One Christmas (about 1911) we had a family gathering at our home with a nice tree in the kitchen. Most of the folks had been there overnight, staying at our home and Grandmother Butler’s, across the lane, so Christmas morning we surely had a jolly time, distributing gifts for all, visiting, eating, and enjoying the day. As I remember there were present John’s mother, Grandma Butler, and her unmarried children, Jane, Taylor, Eva and Lee Tom--, Horace and Ida and their children, Erin and Caroline and children. There may have been others. This was the last Christmas that Grandma Butler was with us. The next year she was in Utah, and died after returning to her home in Idaho, April 21, 1913.

The Christmas of 1912, Jess and Olive Smith were living  in Grandmother Butler’s home, and there we had a nice Christmas party, the Butlers and Smiths all joining together and the next morning, December 26, Horace Smith was born. I was present.

The Christmas of 1914 is one I shall never forget. Our dear father was very ill. He had left home the 2nd of December, going to a Salt Lake Clinic and from there he was sent to the Mayo Clinic in Rochester, Minnesota, where on the 8th of January 1915 he underwent a very serious operation, having a papilloma or tumor removed from his bladder. He was in very critical condition, but through having a good clean body, uncontaminated with liquor or tobacco, tea or coffee, his blood was pure and soon he was on the way to recovery. We felt that the blessings of our Heavenly Father had been with him. He was never very well after this time, but lived 22 ½ years longer, caring for his loved ones. This Christmas day we at home had all received gifts from our dear one. Mine was a nice warm robe which I needed as the weather was severely cold – the thermometer registered 20° below zero for many days at a time. My brother Erin came for us and took us to his home for Christmas dinner. The next day Grant had his arm broken by a horse falling on him. Taylor was caring for the place and he took us to Soldier, 7 miles, to the doctor. This was an added worry and one we did not tell father about until he came home the 2nd of February.

We moved from Manard, on Camas Prairie, to Acequia in September 1917. Our Christmas tree this year was a big sagebrush, as we had not been able to get an evergreen. This substitute was pretty when fixed up, but the odor of sage permeated the house. It was this Christmas that we got our second Victrola, a portable square-shaped box which we enjoyed very much. Our first Victrola was an Edison with a large horn attached to it and was the first, and about the only one, available to our many friends while we lived at Manard. Our home was a place where relatives and friends were always welcome and this music was especially entertaining to all of us. It was at this 1917 Ward Christmas program that Donald contracted whooping cough, so for the next several weeks we were all at home either sick or caring for those having whooping cough, as all seven of our children had it during this time. The next Christmas we had a player piano brought to the house to try it out. We decided we did not want a player piano so returned it and got another one which we had a long as we kept our home. The three older girls became quite efficient in playing it. Edith now has this piano in her home.

We moved from Acequia to Twin Falls in March 1922, living in a nice home on a ten-acre lot north of town. After two years here we moved into town and lived on Adams Street. We had lost our home and practically everything we had owned, so now were renting. The Christmas of 1925 was indeed a trying one. Father and the boys had been farming a place at Filer, about seven miles away. They had had a very hard year; the bean crops they were raising were almost a failure, barely paying expenses of the summer. Very much discouraged, father left on the 20th of December for contact, Nevada to get work in the mines. He worked here for two months, earning $100 per month, and was cheated out of three-fourths of this amount. Christmas, with father gone, was lonely. Gladys was clerking in Wright’s store and did all she could to help us. Uncle Lee came to visit us during this winter and found our coal bin about empty and us, hoping to get money soon to get our supply. He bought us a ton of coal, for which we were grateful. Uncle Lee was surely a Santa Claus, though a little late. Delta Duffin was with us for awhile.

We moved from Twin Falls to a farm near Hollister, 18 miles south, in September 1926. This farm was leased from E.J. Hunt and Sons of Buhl, Idaho, and was known as the Beatty farm. We were there seven years. Each Christmas brought its joys to us. Grant, Edith, Donald and Gladys were all married and we had our family gatherings as often as we could, the grandchildren coming to brighten the day.

The Christmas of 1930 Gladys and her boyfriend (Ervin) came from Lyman, Wyoming, where she was teaching school. They announced the marriage of Donald and Marie Bosch in Salt Lake. We had expected Donald to come home for Christmas, but he did not get home until the next Christmas, then brought his wife and baby Donna Marie.

The Christmas of 1932 we had dinner at Edith’s home, 336 6th Avenue North, in Twin Falls. It was the last Christmas that my mother was with us, as she died the next Thanksgiving day, November 30, 1933. I had had an operation in the Twin Falls Hospital the latter part of October 1932, so was feeling too well at Christmas. Glenn was attending college at Caldwell, Idaho. Etta and Ross were both working for Hunts at Buhl. At Christmas time Ross had received a five-dollar bill for his work, and when he reached home it was gone, no place to be found, which was a great disappointment to him.

In 1933 we moved from Hollister to the Gettert farm (80 acres) three miles west of Eden and thirteen miles northeast of Twin. Here we lived until August 1937, when I made the move to Shelley, Idaho, where I bought a home. My husband had died the month before and we were not in a position to continue renting the farm, so considered it best to make this move. Grant’s home was at Shelley, and the other boys were in school. Glenn and Ross were at the U. of I. at Moscow. Each Christmas brought its joys and remembrances. The boys usually came home from school and the married children and their families came when they could.

I think it was the Christmas of 1935 that Glenn and Ross were coming home from Moscow to be home for the holidays. They did not have enough money to buy their tickets on the train so were going to hitchhike, and against regulations they chose to ride the cars that were bringing students home. They would get on top, or underneath or wherever they could find a place to ride. The train officials discovered them and put them off a time or two, but when the train started again they would be on it. Finally, before reaching Boise, the train officials phoned ahead and had some officers on hand to arrest them. They tried to escape by running but were caught and taken to the lock-up. They were so dirty, covered with coal dust, smoke, etc., that they did not look like white people. At the jail they washed up as best they could and were given a very good meal which they needed and relished very much. The keepers had taken things from their pockets, among which was a letter from their father, telling them of his hopes of having them home for Christmas, also enclosing some money for them. After about five hours in jail, some officers came and talked to them, and in asking questions found that they were not criminals, but just two homesick boys trying to get home for Christmas. He gave them some advice and released them to go on their journey. We had a very happy reunion.

The Christmas of 1937 I spent at Grant’s. I had my home in Shelley and had four lady boarders who had gone home for Christmas. Agnes was at home and Jack was completing his high school. The Christmas before that, 1936, Etta came from Salt Lake with Horace. Glenn and Ross also came from Moscow.

For Christmas of 1938 I made the trip to Moscow, Idaho, to spend it with my four sons. Donald was working at Spokane, Glenn at Lewiston, and Ross and Jack were in school. Margie was there also. I got a ride from Jerome with a Mrs. Jenkins. Melvin took me from Twin to Jerome and we started about 3 a.m., December 20th. It was a very foggy day, and hard to follow the road. Mrs. Jenkins was going to Moscow to bring her son and some other students home for the holidays, then take them back for school, and bring me home again. We arrived safely in Moscow about 5 p.m. and surely enjoyed meeting my dear ones again. Margie made the trip to Boise to visit her parents, so I spent most of the next two weeks there very much alone. The four sons were all there with us for Christmas dinner.

I went to a dentist and had my only nine bottom teeth drawn, and got a full set of new teeth made. It was rather a painful ordeal, but a job I needed to have done. Glenn was the one to settle this account. It was a fine Christmas present for me. It was also this Christmas that I received my Parker fountain pen from my children. It has done me a lot of service and I am writing with it now.

Mrs. Jenkins came back to Moscow in due time and we were to go home the next day, but a snow storm had started and she was afraid that the road over the Blue Ridge Mountains would be blocked before morning, so we decided to start that night. We left Moscow about 7 p.m. and had a very disagreeable time, all night. The storm was a bad one, rain, hail, wind and sleet taking turns. As we reached the top of the divide we met a man driving a big oil truck. He put the chains on our car, which helped some, as we were having trouble keeping on the road. This driver said if we had more trouble he would be along and give us help. We went a short distance and found our engine radiator was dry. We stopped and waited for the oil truck, but he passed us by without stopping. We would go a little way until the engine heated up, then stop to cool it. We kept this up until we reached a highway station where we got water and continued on our way. Mrs. Jenkins had been without sleep for a long time and her eyes became so inflamed and sore that she could hardly see. When we reached Emmett we went to her cousin’s place and stayed a couple of hours, resting and bathing her eyes. We reached Boise about 5 p.m. where I stopped for a few days.

Christmas of 1940 was in Logan. Agnes and I attended early pageant.

The Christmas of 1941 I was living in Logan until September. I rode to Twin Falls with a neighbor (Mr. Smith) in August. Went to Twin Falls from Salt Lake for Christmas with Edith and family. Jack came from Moscow and met me there. We had a fine dinner and a generous good time. Melvin took Jack and me to Acequia after dinner, where we stayed with Uncle Horace and Aunt Ida. Melvin came for us on Saturday morning and took us to Shelley where we visited with Grant and family, also went to Idaho Falls and visited with Agnes and Roland. Jack returned back to Salt Lake with me where he visited Etta and family. Gladys and family came while he was here. They stayed just a short time.

I moved to Salt Lake to be with Etta in September 1941 and here I was for Christmas, but went to Twin Falls to meet Jack and visit. Etta was working and I was keeping house and caring for her children. We had a very nice Christmas tree and many nice presents. I received many cards and tokens, also several dollars in money from my children.

The Christmas of 1942 was spent in Salt Lake with Etta and family. Jack did not come home this year.


Now it is nearly Christmas of 1943. I am here at Hill Field working. I have a very comfortable little room where I am able to do some of the things I like to do. This day (Monday, December 20) has been my day off and I have spent a lot of time writing about Christmases I remember. I have remembered a lot of things I am glad to get recorded so our children will know about them. I have had photographs of father and myself made and sent to the nine of our children. Hope they will enjoy them. Jack is far away from the rest of the family right now, but we hope he is well and happy.

Thursday, September 7, 2017

Lessons in Partnership


September 1, 2017

Fifty years ago today I walked into Charlie Swan’s office located above Flying Realty in Vale. I was dressed in a rather dapper suit wearing a white shirt with a skinny tie, which was the fashion in 1967. I told him I was ready to go to work and we began practicing law together as Swan & Butler.

Bob Butler just a few weeks after starting to practice law with Charlie Swan 1967

I had completed moving Sandy and our three sons from Eugene into the Quisenberry house next door to Bob Harrod on Clark Street. Jared was then about two weeks old.  I didn’t know whether I had passed the Oregon Bar exam or not but I did know that I was unemployed and had a wife and three children. We had a little money left from the sale of our home at 863 E. 22nd St. in Eugene. We had used a bunch of it to buy some furniture and appliances and to move to Vale. I hoped we could survive until I could start making some money from the law practice.

Charlie and I agreed that whatever money we made from this new law firm, we would split it equally, half and half. He and I visited about some legal matters that he was working on and I think our first “new” client was a lady wanting a divorce. Even though I had graduated from law school and taken the Oregon Bar exam, I had absolutely no idea how to practice law. Charlie had to mentor me every step of the way.

It was a couple of weeks or so later that someone mentioned to me that the Bar exam results were in the Portland Oregonian newspaper that morning. I ran down to the drug store and bought an Oregonian. I searched through it until I found the list, ran my finger down the list until I found my name. I don’t recall that I was particularly surprised that I had passed as I hadn’t given any thought to what would happen if I didn’t pass. I just knew it couldn’t happen because I needed to take care of my family.

To me, it doesn’t seem like it was all that long ago this all happened. Fifty years have flown by and many changes have taken place. Lots of water, good and bad, has flown under the bridge and here we are, two old people with lots of health issues but happy and still in love. We consider our family as our greatest accomplishment and treasure. We thank our Heavenly Father daily for each of our posterity and we pray for their happiness and success.

Bob and Sandy

The Malheur Enterprise Newspaper published the following story about Bob Butler, Charlie Swan, and Cliff Looney...

Legal Eagles: Vale lawyers build successful partnership

Legal Eagles: Vale lawyers build successful partnership




VALE – He was a former candy salesman turned lawyer.
In 1927, Charles Swan set up a law practice in Vale and a half century later his partners remembered his efforts as they looked ahead for what is now known as Butler & Looney P.C.
Bob Butler and Cliff Looney on Nov. 18 welcomed clients and friends to a celebration of 50 years the law firm has served eastern Oregon, Idaho and beyond. The get together was a testament to two individuals with differing views on about everything who walked into the office each day, building a successful law firm while making friends.
“We differ on politics, the recent election and what cases we choose to take,” said Looney. “But we can start a sentence and the other one can finish it we know each other so well.”
The two came into practice differently. Butler joined Swan in 1967. Looney, after serving one term as the Malheur County district attorney, joined the two in early 1970s.
“We are probably the only firm that has ever taken on the state on level of care at nursing homes and that is one I am extremely proud of,” Looney recalled. “It was a case that was important to the people of this community.”
In that case, Looney argued doctors servicing nursing homes around the state were better qualified to determine what a patient needed rather than a state official in Salem. The court ruled for Looney’s clients.
Even with more than 50 years of practice and a new home in Boise, Looney isn’t ready to step down.
“I have come to the point where I can be picky on what cases I take,” he said. “I plan on going at least one more year. I have clients who are now coming here that are fourth generation. We have taken care of their great grandparents and they still trust us enough to deal with their issues. That says something about the trust we have built through time and the relationships we have in this community.”
Looney takes his profession seriously.
“The law has been here for over 2,000 years,” he said. “Law is absolutely necessary.”
“The law involves personal things with people,” said Butler. “You very often see people at their deepest, darkest moments.”
Like his partner, Butler sees the relationships built through the years as the greatest accomplishment for the firm.
“It is the association we have made with people that is the greatest thing,” said Butler. “Sometimes, we meet people and the chemistry is just not there and we understand that. People come to us when they are desperate and need help.”
Both credit their success to Swan, a friend and colleague until his death in 1994.
Swan was born March 24, 1900, the oldest of six children. When he was 14, his father left for a mining venture in California, never to return. The family farm was foreclosed and the family evicted.
Swan quit school in the eighth grade, taking a job selling candy for the Idaho Candy Company. Travelling to mining towns throughout Idaho, he supported the family.
At age 21, Swan returned to school in Portland after meeting Dr. William Judson Boone, the founding president of the College of Idaho while hitchhiking. Paying his tuition in installments and living in the local YMCA, Swan took two newspaper routes to pay for school.
After completing high school, Swan moved to Salem and enrolled in Willamette University. While there, he met and married Marguerite Fay Spaulding, his wife of 66 years.
After obtaining his law degree, the couple moved to Newberg. With the nation entering the Great Depression, Fay moved to Crane to teach with Swan visiting as often as possible.
In 1927, Swan and his wife moved to Vale as he went into practice with Robert D. Lytle.
In the early 1940s, Swan accepted the position as district attorney, a position he held until 1954. Butler, who grew up next to Swan, joined the practice with Looney entering a few years later. Swan continued to practice law until he was 88. He continued to go to the office with his Irish setter.
“Since I was five, I knew I wanted to be a lawyer,” Butler said. “I used to go to Charlie’s office with my dad and it was always warm and smelled good.”
“Looking back, if I was not a lawyer, I would have been a history professor,” Looney said. “I was always afraid though I would never be as good a professor as those I learned from. I made the right decision in going into law.”

Sunday, April 2, 2017

My Grandmother's Clock

I wanted to share a recent experience of mine. One of those life moments when we realize it is time to change directions and slow down and pull the 'inner' strength needed to continue on. My family will remember the old mantle clock we grew up with and it's special sound.
MY GRANDMOTHER’s CLOCK
Molly (Aultz) Vanorden
On a cloudy day when winter’s grasp was releasing spring, she came. 

Fragile and worn, she was delivered from a place I had never been, a time I had never known, a thousand miles and a century away. She was born in a time before electric lights, modern conveniences, television, and twitter. An ambassador of a gentler age, her embellishments were now faded, dark wood patina softened, small inclusions in green marble, a testament to her resiliency. Her work continued day and night. With loving care she marked the passage of time, events large and small, a birth, the return of a loved one from work, time to release the cares of the waning day as the sunset announced the dusk.

Even across the expanse of time and distance, I remembered her. She was a sister to one given to my great grandparents on their wedding day. Growing up I had fond memories of her gentle sound. Marking each minute her gentle tick-tock would beat like a heart, never failing. A low resonant sound marked the hours as her pendulum gently struck. In her sound, I could hear and feel loved ones and homes now passed. The sound was familiar and peaceful. 

Her original face, burnished mechanism, pendulum and winding key came carefully packaged. I gently freed her from the cocoon of paper and bubble wrap. I was too young when I had seen her last to remember exactly how to initiate the tick and the tock. With several turns of the winding key and pendulum adjustment, she came to life for me. I marveled that she could keep perfect time just as she had for over a century, no electricity, no batteries, no digital signal. 


With the television in the background, and the finishing of the dishes for the day, a thought occurred to me – the clock must be broken? She wasn’t making any noise. No tick-tock was discernable. The deep gong of the hour I could hear but it seemed so far away.
And then I realized…..
I finished my work and turned off the TV. I sat quietly. I listened and as I listened she became louder and louder ‘tick-tock, tick-tock’. I closed my eyes and memories washed over me. In the forgotten stillness of all those years, she was the same. cheerfully marking the minutes and hours. There were no TV’s in my grandmother’s house, no cell phones ringing, no overwhelming sounds to diminish the profound silence. 

And in that day, I remembered the beauty of quiet and a simpler time, a slower time. 

I pondered how much of life I had missed because of the noise, the chaos, the endless banter. Voices are louder, life is faster, families do not sit down together when the pendulum resonates the sacred hour, we are too busy, we are all in different places, but in that evening, in a quiet home, the clock’s pendulum resonated. Her beautiful sound penetrated me, and for the first time in years, I could hear my soul.


~In loving memory of my Great Grandparents Dot 'Dear Mom' and Ezra Josef Werry